A while ago I read in my sister's blog about a debate that had been going on between her and her friends about the Taiwan/China controversy. For those of you who aren't really familiar with this issue: it's a really touchy topic, and I wish I had some links to information about it. But you can read the debate in their journals here, here, and here. (If you really want to understand where I'm coming from when I write this entry, you should read all of those links.)
So first of all, it surprises me that my sister's friends are even having a debate about such a controversial issue as this. Secondly, the depth, maturity, and (in most cases) understanding that they're showing in their journal entries amazes and impresses me. (I don't mean to sound condescending by saying that; my sister's a freshman in high school, which isn't young at all--but my thoughts tend to get skewed, just because, well, she's my little sister.)
It's been a while since I've had to face this issue, but this past weekend it unexpectedly reared its ugly head, almost touching on exactly the same things that my sister and her friends had been debating in their journals. Sunday we had a staff meeting for next year, and before the meeting began the six girls from my building were just chatting. Brown Residence Hall--the building I'll be a PL in--is a small dorm, and out of the six PLs, four of us are Asian. We were talking about where we were from (which isn't really the right thing to ask, since I'm "from" Miami, but whatever):
Yalan: "I'm Chinese."
Sheila: "Filipino."
Adrian (who's not Asian), turning to me: "Chinese, right?"
Me, shaking my head: "No, I'm Taiwanese."
Yalan, rolling her eyes, which annoys me more than I let on: "It's the same thing! You're Chinese."
Charlene: "Yeah, my parents are from Taiwan, but I consider myself Chinese."
What was I supposed to do? All I could say was, "I'm Taiwanese; let's not start." And thankfully the meeting began, and the subject was dropped.
But that makes me question my own beliefs. How strongly do I feel? Not strongly enough to argue about it with the girls in my section; especially since I don't think anyone's views would change.
What also makes it difficult is that I can't speak about it objectively. Ever since I can remember, my parents, and other members of the Taiwanese community, have pounded it into my head: that I'm Taiwanese and not Chinese, that whenever someone asks you what nationality you are, that's what you should answer, no matter what dismissive things people might say. I have memories of situations like this as far back as elementary school, as far back as first or second grade.
But it's been a while since I've had a confrontation, and what happened Sunday reminded me that it's a very real thing that I have to deal with, no matter how much I try to avoid it by not joining organizations like CSA and shit (which is entirely another entry in itself).
But reading some of the debate going on in my sister's journal, I've noticed some points that I keep coming back to, and while they don't makes things clearer, they're something to think about. First of all, it's sad when this sort of thing comes between friends, and I'm glad that Christine and Robin didn't let it ruin their friendship, because it's almost happened to me before. And I would rather it not be an issue next year when it comes to working with my building staff.
Secondly, there's the question about whether I consider myself more American than Taiwanese. Vincent, another one of my sister's friends, wrote that he considers himself American. Just that: not Taiwanese or Chinese; therefore, the issue of Taiwan/China is moot. But I can't entirely agree with that, either. It's true that I consider myself more American than Taiwanese--because hell, I grew up here, and along with growing up here comes American culture and lifestyle and education. But still, it's like... even though the fabric that makes up me is made in America, there's bits and pieces of Taiwanese thread--beliefs and habits and how I was brought up, even the seemingly superficial stuff like Taiwanese food and whatever--that's intertwined in there, too. When I visit Taiwan, I don't feel like a stranger; part of me wishes I were more in tune with my Taiwanese heritage.
And then there's the question of just how much of this issue is my own belief, and how much is my parents'? I don't know; I can't separate the two.
So despite my attempts at objectivity, I have to say this: if you're Chinese-American, and you refuse to acknowledge that Taiwan is fighting for democracy, when you are living in a country that is the epitome (whether it be entirely true or not) of democracy, how is that not hypocritical? Isn't there something inherently flawed?
But. There's more to the post than politics, because, frankly, I don't know much about politics.
The point is this: I am really proud of my sister. It surprises me how strongly she feels about this, and the events of the past few days have made me appreciate that. And it also makes me realize that I underestimate her sometimes. Even though I'm the older sister, and am supposed to set the example, I forget sometimes that... there's a lot I can learn from her, too.